Skip to content
The American Surcharge

A sourced catalog of what Americans pay that people in other wealthy countries don't.

Country comparison

The United States and Germany

Germany

Almost 90 percent1 of people in Germany have statutory health insurance. It is paid for by a contribution on gross wages that employer and employee split, and spouses and children with little or no income are covered without contributions of their own.2 Co-payments are small flat amounts, and the yearly total is capped as a share of income.3 This profile covers health care only so far; other areas are added as their entries are sourced.

Every item, side by side

  1. COBRA

    Unique

    In the USWhen Americans lose or leave a job, a federal law lets them keep the employer's health plan for a limited time, as long as they pay the whole premium themselves plus a surcharge. It exists because coverage is tied to the job. In peer countries coverage doesn't end when a job does.

    In GermanyPeople receiving unemployment benefit stay in statutory health insurance, and their contributions are usually paid by the agency that pays the benefit.12
  2. Medical debt and bankruptcy

    Unique

    In the USMedical debt is the most common kind of debt in collections on American credit records. Hospitals can sue patients, garnish wages, and place liens on property to collect it. Where hospital and doctor care isn't billed to the patient, or the patient's share is capped, this kind of debt has little to grow from.

    In GermanyCo-payments exist, but the yearly total is capped at 2 percent of gross income3, or 1 percent for people with a chronic illness3.3
  3. Medicare premiums, Medigap, and IRMAA

    Unique

    In the USTurning sixty-five in the US doesn't end the premiums. Medicare Part B has a monthly premium, drug coverage under Part D is a separate plan with its own premium, a Medigap policy is another, and higher earners pay an income-related surcharge. In Germany, pensioners simply stay in the same statutory insurance that covers employees.

    In GermanyPensioners are generally members of statutory health insurance, the same system that covers employees and trainees.2
  4. Deductibles, copays, and coinsurance

    Higher

    In the USPaying the premium is the first bill. Insured Americans then pay again when they use care: a deductible before most coverage starts, copays at the desk, and coinsurance as a share of the bill. Peer countries have cost sharing too, but it is a small flat fee or capped as a share of income, and for hospital and doctor care in some of them it is zero.

    In GermanyCo-payments are mostly between 5 and 10 euros3. The yearly total is capped at 2 percent of gross income3, or 1 percent for people with a chronic illness3. The cap isn't automatic: the patient has to apply to the insurance fund each year. Children are exempt.3
  5. Ground ambulance

    Higher

    In the USIn the US an ambulance ride is a billable service that is usually outside the patient's insurance network, and it was left out of the federal law on surprise bills. Peer countries charge for ambulances in some cases too, which is why this entry is tagged higher rather than unique.

    In GermanyWhen a health insurance fund covers travel costs, the patient normally pays a tenth of the cost, with a minimum of 5 euros and a maximum of 10 euros3.3
  6. Health insurance premiums

    Higher

    In the USMost working Americans pay a monthly premium for health coverage, and their employer pays a larger share on top. Peer countries fund coverage through taxes or through contributions set as a share of income. Some, like the Netherlands, do charge a premium, which is why this entry is tagged higher rather than unique.

    In GermanyStatutory health insurance is paid as a share of gross wages, at a standard rate of 14.6 percent2 split evenly between worker and employer, plus a supplementary rate that varies by insurance fund. Spouses and children with little or no income are covered without paying contributions of their own.2
  7. Prescription drug prices

    Higher

    In the USAmericans pay far more than people in other countries for brand-name prescription drugs. Unbranded generics are the exception: they cost less in the US than in most countries.

    In GermanyA patient pays a tenth of a prescription's price, with a minimum of 5 euros and a maximum of 10 euros3. For drugs that have equivalent alternatives, a reference price sets the most the insurance funds will pay, and the patient covers the difference only if the doctor prescribes something above it.?3

Sources

  1. Health insurance. gesund.bund.de (Federal Ministry of Health, Germany), April 16, 2024. primary government · accessed November 18, 2026
  2. Healthy in Germany: Everything you need to know about the healthcare system in Germany. Federal Ministry of Health (Germany), June 1, 2026. primary government · accessed November 18, 2026
  3. Co-payments and exemption from co-payment. gesund.bund.de (Federal Ministry of Health, Germany), March 15, 2023. primary government · accessed November 18, 2026