Skip to content
The American Surcharge

A sourced catalog of what Americans pay that people in other wealthy countries don't.

Method

This site makes an argument, so it has to be easy to check. These are the rules every entry is held to, and they are enforced by the build: a page that breaks them cannot be published.

What counts as evidence

Every figure, quote, date, and claim on the site is tied to a source you can open. If a number is not in a source we can cite, it does not appear; the page shows nothing rather than a plausible guess.

Primary sources are preferred and required: OECD, WHO, KFF, the Commonwealth Fund, the CFPB, the FTC, the BLS, the Census Bureau, the CBO, the GAO, the Federal Reserve, court records, statutes, official government pages of the comparison country, and peer-reviewed papers.

Secondary sources, meaning major newspapers, Reuters, and the AP, are accepted as support and flagged as such. They are never the only source behind a published claim.

Not accepted at all: listicles, forum posts, videos, opinion blogs, and Wikipedia. Wikipedia is used only to find the primary source it cites.

A quote attributed to a real person links to the transcript, press release, post, or article where it was actually said. There are no paraphrased or reconstructed quotes.

Draft, unverified, verified

Every entry carries one of three states. Draft means it is being written and may contain placeholders. Unverified means it is complete and every claim has a source attached, but nobody has yet opened each source and confirmed it says what we say it says. Verified means someone has. Only verified entries appear on this site. The other two exist only in an editorial view that is never built into the public site.

How the tags are calibrated

Unique
Essentially only the US among high-income countries.
Higher
Exists elsewhere, but the US pays far more, or out of pocket.
Cultural
A norm rather than a policy.
Reverse
The US is cheaper. Same rigor, opposite direction.

The comparison set is high-income countries: Canada, the United Kingdom, Germany, France, the Netherlands, Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Finland, Japan, Australia, New Zealand, and Switzerland. "Higher" is never upgraded to "Unique" for effect. Where the US is cheaper, the entry goes in the reverse section with the same rigor, and that section stays in the navigation.

Voice

Plain and dry. No outrage, no partisan vocabulary. The facts are meant to carry the weight; the reader can draw the conclusions.

Report an error

Every page has a "Report an error" link. The reporting channel is not open yet, so for now that link brings you here. When it opens, it will prefill a report with the page and the claim in question, and confirmed errors will be fixed and logged below.

Corrections log

No corrections yet.